익명 02:04

It-cleft sentence or what?

It-cleft sentence or what?

I couldn't figure out the logic of this sentence. I heard it in a dialogue in a film. I have never seen such a pattern in grammar books. But as a result of my researches, I saw that it was examined in the subject of "it cleft," but unfortunately I did not understand this pattern again.

"I know what it is you need."



Top Answer/Comment:

Suppose you have the following sentence:

(1) You need food.

If we turn this sentence into an it-cleft, it becomes:

(2) It is food that you need.

And if we turn this it-cleft into a "wh- question," we get:

(3) What is it that you need?

Here, in (3), we have what's called "subject-auxiliary inversion"—the auxiliary (is) moves to a position that precedes the subject (it). But if we embed a wh- question into a declarative sentence, there is no inversion (at least in Standard English). So, if we embed (3) into a declarative sentence, we would get something like (4), where there is no inversion:

(4) I know what it is that you need.

The complementizer (that) is optional in this sentence, so we can change this to:

(4') I know what it is you need.

And that's basically the sentence you were asking about, or at least a declarative version of it. Depending on the intonation (or punctuation in writing), the sentence in (4') can become a question without any change in word order, in which case it may mean what DrMoishe Pippik suggested in an earlier answer: "Do you think that I know what it is that you need??"

상단 광고의 [X] 버튼을 누르면 내용이 보입니다